Sciatica or Lower Back Pain? How to Tell the Difference

Where the pain travels, what it feels like and what helps: a clear guide to telling nerve pain from back pain, and when to get it checked.

Written by the Somatic Recovery team · How we writeFact-checked 6 Oct 20268 min read
Hands holding the calf of a person lying on a treatment table

The quickest way to tell sciatica from ordinary lower back pain is to look at where the pain goes. Lower back pain mostly stays in the back, and sometimes aches into the buttock. Sciatica is nerve pain that travels down one leg, often below the knee, and is usually worse in the leg than in the back. It often comes with tingling, numbness or a burning or electric feeling. Both are common, many people improve with time and the right kind of activity, and both should be checked urgently if they come with numbness around the groin, bladder or bowel changes, or worsening leg weakness.

The short version

  • Location is the biggest clue. Back pain stays mostly in the back. Sciatica travels down the leg, often past the knee.
  • Sciatica feels different: sharp, burning, electric or tingling, rather than a dull ache or stiffness.
  • It’s a symptom, not a diagnosis. It usually comes from an irritated nerve root in the lower back, most often near a disc.
  • Many people improve. In one large study, just over half of people with back-related leg pain had improved meaningfully at 12 months, and expecting it to last a long time was linked to slower recovery.
  • Some signs are emergencies: groin or saddle numbness, bladder or bowel changes, sciatica in both legs, or a weakening leg.

What is sciatica?

Sciatica is the name for pain that follows the path of the sciatic nerve, which runs from the lower back through the buttock and down the back of the leg. Clinicians often call it lumbar radicular pain, because it comes from irritation or compression of a nerve root (the “radix”) where it leaves the spine.1

The most common cause is a disc bulge or herniation pressing on or inflaming a nerve root. Narrowing of the spaces the nerves pass through (stenosis), which is more common with age, is another. Sciatica is a description of where symptoms are felt, not a diagnosis of exactly what is happening, which is why an assessment matters.

How common it is depends on how it’s defined. A review of studies found estimates ranging from about 1% to over 40%, mostly because studies used very different definitions.2 What is clear is that it’s a common reason people seek help for back problems.

Sciatica or lower back pain: how to tell the difference

Lower back painSciatica
Where it hurts mostLower back, sometimes into the buttock or upper thighDown one leg, often below the knee into the calf or foot
What it feels likeDull ache, stiffness, muscle tightness or spasmSharp, shooting, burning or electric; often with tingling
Leg vs backBack usually hurts moreLeg usually hurts more than the back
Other sensationsRarely numbnessPins and needles, numbness, sometimes weakness in the leg or foot
What tends to aggravate itBending, lifting, staying in one positionSitting, bending forward, coughing or sneezing

These are patterns, not rules. Back pain can refer an ache into the thigh without any nerve involvement, and some people have both back pain and sciatica at the same time. A physical assessment helps sort out which is which.

Referred pain vs nerve pain

Not all leg pain is sciatica. Irritated joints, discs and muscles in the lower back can produce referred pain: a vague, deep ache spread over the buttock and thigh that usually stops above the knee and doesn’t come with numbness or tingling.

Nerve root pain tends to be sharper and more precisely felt, follows a line down the leg, often goes below the knee, and can come with changes in sensation, reflexes or strength in a specific area. The distinction matters because the two are treated a little differently and have different outlooks.

How a physiotherapist assesses it

An assessment starts with your story: where the pain goes, what makes it better or worse, and whether there are any warning signs. The physical examination may include:

  • Movement tests to see how bending and other movements change your back and leg symptoms
  • Nerve tension tests such as the straight leg raise and the slump test, which gently stretch the nerve to see if they reproduce your leg pain
  • Neurological checks of sensation, reflexes and muscle strength in the legs and feet

No single test is decisive. A Cochrane review found that most physical tests used on their own are only moderately accurate for identifying a disc problem pressing on a nerve, and that combining findings works better.3 That’s why the overall picture matters more than any one test.

Do you need a scan?

Usually not at first. Scans are most useful when symptoms are severe or getting worse, when a red flag is present, or when treatment such as an injection or surgery is being considered. The UK’s NICE guideline advises against routine imaging in non-specialist settings for low back pain with or without sciatica.4 Many disc changes seen on MRI are also common in people without pain, so a scan on its own doesn’t always explain your symptoms.

What helps sciatica

Most sciatica settles with time and conservative care, although nerve pain can take longer to ease than ordinary back pain. Approaches that are commonly part of a plan include:

  • Staying as active as you comfortably can. Bed rest isn’t recommended. Short walks and changing position regularly usually help more.
  • Finding positions that ease the leg pain. Many people find some positions calm the nerve, such as lying on their side with a pillow between the knees.
  • Graded exercise chosen from your assessment, building from gentle movement to strengthening as symptoms settle. NICE recommends considering exercise programmes for low back pain with or without sciatica.4
  • Hands-on treatment alongside exercise, which NICE suggests considering as part of a wider treatment package.4
  • Understanding the pain. Knowing that nerve pain can feel alarming without meaning serious damage often makes it easier to keep moving.

Medication is a decision for your doctor. It’s worth knowing that NICE advises against using gabapentinoids, other anti-epileptic drugs, oral corticosteroids or benzodiazepines for sciatica, and against opioids for chronic sciatica.4 For severe sciatica that doesn’t improve, doctors may discuss an epidural injection, or referral to a spinal surgeon if scan findings match the symptoms.4

Small things that often help in the first weeks

  • Break up sitting every 20 to 30 minutes, especially when driving.
  • Walk little and often rather than one long walk.
  • Avoid long periods of bending forward, such as long sessions on a low sofa.
  • Keep a short note of what makes the leg pain better or worse. It’s useful for your assessment.

How long does sciatica last?

It varies widely. In the ATLAS study, which followed 609 people with back-related leg pain in primary care, 55% had improved meaningfully after 12 months, both in the group as a whole and in those with confirmed sciatica.5 Longer-lasting leg pain before seeking help, and believing that the problem would last a long time, were linked to slower recovery.

That last point is worth noting. How you understand the problem can affect how it goes, which is one reason a clear explanation and a plan are part of good care. You can read about how we approach this on our back pain treatment in Dubai page.

Seek urgent medical care if you have

  • Numbness or tingling around the groin, genitals, buttocks or inner thighs
  • New difficulty passing urine, or loss of bladder or bowel control
  • Sciatica in both legs
  • Weakness in a leg or foot that is getting worse, such as a foot that drags

These can be signs of cauda equina syndrome, which needs same-day emergency assessment. In the UAE, call 998 for an ambulance.

When to see a physiotherapist

Consider an assessment if leg pain is stopping you sleeping, working or moving normally, hasn’t started to ease after a couple of weeks, or keeps coming back. A physiotherapist can work out whether your symptoms are more likely to be nerve-related or referred from the back, explain what’s going on, and build a plan for activity and exercise. If anything points to a problem that needs a doctor or a scan, they’ll refer you on. If you’re new to physiotherapy, here’s what to expect at your first session, and if sitting makes things worse, see our guide to lower back pain from sitting all day.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if my pain is sciatica or just back pain?

Sciatica usually travels down one leg, often below the knee, and is felt as sharp, burning or electric pain, sometimes with tingling or numbness. Ordinary back pain mostly stays in the back or buttock and feels more like an ache or stiffness. A physiotherapist can confirm which it is with a few simple tests.

Can sciatica go away on its own?

Many cases improve over weeks to months, especially with staying active and appropriate exercise. Some people take longer, so it’s worth getting assessed if leg pain isn’t easing after a couple of weeks or is affecting sleep and daily life.

Is walking good for sciatica?

For most people, yes. Short, regular walks help keep the back and nerve moving and are better than bed rest. If walking makes the leg pain clearly worse, try shorter distances and get advice on what suits your situation.

Should I get an MRI for sciatica?

Not usually at the start. An MRI is helpful when symptoms are severe or getting worse, when there are warning signs, or when an injection or surgery is being considered. Many scan findings are common in people without pain, so a scan alone may not explain your symptoms.

When is sciatica an emergency?

Seek emergency care straight away if sciatica comes with numbness around the groin or buttocks, new bladder or bowel problems, symptoms in both legs, or weakness in the leg that is getting worse. In the UAE, call 998.

References

  1. Jensen RK, Kongsted A, Kjaer P, Koes B. Diagnosis and treatment of sciatica. BMJ. 2019;367:l6273.
  2. Konstantinou K, Dunn KM. Sciatica: review of epidemiological studies and prevalence estimates. Spine. 2008;33(22):2464-2472.
  3. van der Windt DA, Simons E, Riphagen II, et al. Physical examination for lumbar radiculopathy due to disc herniation in patients with low-back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010;(2):CD007431.
  4. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Low back pain and sciatica in over 16s: assessment and management (NG59).
  5. Konstantinou K, Dunn KM, Ogollah R, et al. Prognosis of sciatica and back-related leg pain in primary care: the ATLAS cohort. Spine J. 2018;18(6):1030-1040.
Shubhangii Gaikwaad, DHA-Licensed Physiotherapist

About Somatic Recovery

Somatic Recovery is the Dubai practice of Shubhangii Gaikwaad, DHA-Licensed Physiotherapist (MPT, Neurology) with 16 years of clinical experience. Sessions in person in Dubai and online worldwide, in English and Hindi.

This article is general information, not a diagnosis or a substitute for an individual assessment. If you have severe, sudden or worsening symptoms, see a doctor.

Somatic Recovery · Dubai & online

Want this looked at properly?

One assessment with a DHA-licensed physiotherapist to understand what is driving your symptoms, with a clear plan and an honest timeline.